Skip to content
CrossTech is part of The Platinum Network. Become a Member!
  • enEnglish
  • esEspañol
  • pt-brPortuguês
Linkedin page opens in new windowYouTube page opens in new windowTwitter page opens in new windowFacebook page opens in new windowInstagram page opens in new window
CrossTech
Cross Border Payments
CrossTechCrossTech
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Board of Directors
    • Who comes to CROSSTECH?
    • Industry Associations
    • WOMEN IN THE MONEY TRANSFER INDUSTRY AWARDS
    • IDFR – International Day of Family Remittances
    • Contact Us
  • Conferences
    • PAYMENTS 2023
    • Past Conferences
      • IMTC WORLD
        • WORLD 2022
        • IMTC WORLD 2021
        • IMTC WORLD 2020
      • IMTC LATAM
        • LATAM 2022
        • IMTC LATAM 2021
        • IMTC LATAM 2019
      • REGLIANCE
        • REGLIANCE 2021
      • IMTC EMEA
        • IMTC EMEA 2021
        • IMTC EMEA 2019
        • IMTC EMEA 2018
      • IMTC ASIA
        • IMTC ASIA 2018
        • IMTC ASIA 2016
      • IMTC AFRICA
        • IMTC AFRICA 2019
        • IMTC AFRICA 2017
      • IMTC BRASIL
        • IMTC BRASIL 2018
        • IMTC BRASIL 2016
      • REMTECH AWARDS
        • CROSSTECH AWARDS 2022
        • REMTECH 2020
        • REMTECH AWARDS 2019
    • Past & Present Sponsors
    • Past Speakers
    • Past Participants
  • Magazine
  • Blog
Search:
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Board of Directors
    • Who comes to CROSSTECH?
    • Industry Associations
    • WOMEN IN THE MONEY TRANSFER INDUSTRY AWARDS
    • IDFR – International Day of Family Remittances
    • Contact Us
  • Conferences
    • PAYMENTS 2023
    • Past Conferences
      • IMTC WORLD
        • WORLD 2022
        • IMTC WORLD 2021
        • IMTC WORLD 2020
      • IMTC LATAM
        • LATAM 2022
        • IMTC LATAM 2021
        • IMTC LATAM 2019
      • REGLIANCE
        • REGLIANCE 2021
      • IMTC EMEA
        • IMTC EMEA 2021
        • IMTC EMEA 2019
        • IMTC EMEA 2018
      • IMTC ASIA
        • IMTC ASIA 2018
        • IMTC ASIA 2016
      • IMTC AFRICA
        • IMTC AFRICA 2019
        • IMTC AFRICA 2017
      • IMTC BRASIL
        • IMTC BRASIL 2018
        • IMTC BRASIL 2016
      • REMTECH AWARDS
        • CROSSTECH AWARDS 2022
        • REMTECH 2020
        • REMTECH AWARDS 2019
    • Past & Present Sponsors
    • Past Speakers
    • Past Participants
  • Magazine
  • Blog

HOW TELCOS, MTOS AND BANKS COULD CRASH OVER REMITTANCES

You are here:
  1. Home
  2. News & Comments
  3. HOW TELCOS, MTOS AND BANKS…
Sep162014
News & Comments

Incumbents such as Western Union and MoneyGram do it. Traditional players do it. So, still, do some banks. And Telcos do too in some markets. The “it” is enable people to move money to each other in and between countries. Hugo Cuevas-Mohr shares insights gleaned from his work with money transfer professionals from all over the world about the remittance market, the role of traditional players, banks and telcos and who has the edge as this $500 billion industry evolves.

The following are the questions and answers provided by Hugo Cuevas-Mohr when interviewed by PYMNTS.com over his document “Are Telcos, Money Transfer Companies (MTOs) and Banks on a collision course over remittances?” (The document can be downloaded from there).
Click the questions below to open the answers. Please give us your comments and join the conversation here.

Money transfer is a half a trillion-dollar industry and growing. Given your experience what factors are influencing the remittance market today, and how is this industry likely to evolve?

HC: The money transfer market is in influx right now because operators that have dominated the market for a long time like Western Union, MoneyGram, and others are still dominant today. Banks moved into the market – but some are pulling out and many others are now questioning their role in the market. And, more recently, telcos have moved into the market with their mobile wallets. Those three players are getting into very interesting positions all over the world.

It will take more time in the US for mobile wallets to claim a bigger share of the market domestically and internationally. But this isn’t the case in other markets like Latin America, Africa, and Asia. Regulation is also playing a key role. What will happen in the market will depend on how the battles will play out in every country and region in the world..

While it is clear that money transfer operators dominate this market, in the paying side of the equation telco’s are growing their importance. In your opinion, what role will telecom likely play in mobile money and mobile payments?

HC: I think that some things that are happening, for example, in Kenya, are very interesting. We know about mPesa, the mobile wallet that’s been the probably the most successful in the world, and what’s happening now with Equity Bank, the largest bank. They’ve been trying to work together, but they are fighting for a piece of the market. Equity Bank now has a Telecom license to get into the market with their own mobile wallet because it feels it’s been left out by the telcos. That’s happening in Kenya, but it’s also happening in other countries in Africa.

This is very important to watch – it’s about how the regulators use who can hold money. As more people are using mobile phones, they become the tool for telco’s to reach the customer. But who is going to manage the funds? That’s the key question. Governments are realizing that this could be the best tool for financial inclusion, getting more people to use digital money rather than advancing financial literacy. So that regulation will determine who has more power in the market. As the end of the day, it’s the customer who decides what they want and what’s better for them, but regulation is playing a key role.

In Latin America, where banks have more leverage with politicians, there is regulation in place so that banks are not left out and are forced into partnerships with telco’s. Elsewhere, in the Middle East, the UAE has one of the largest outflows of remittances in the world. There, the MTOs have been dominant for a number of years, and telco’s have recently come to that region. Now, the central bank of the UAE is bringing everyone to the table to decide who will be responsible for what.

In the US, the telco role in terms of mobile wallets has shifted over the last year or two. The initial objective of telco was to try and see if they can control the wallet and get a slice of those transactions, but there seems to be more of a second-generation view now that the telcos are letting others do that, while they simply sell the data. Mobile wallets and all of these features will cause people to use more data and bandwidth, and that’s how the telcos will profit. Is that what you’re seeing in the US?

HC: Yes, in the US, the tier one telcos have that strategy. Also, mobile wallets have yet to catch up in the US market. But in the money transfer market, something else is also going on. The tier 2 and 3 telcos that sell airtime services to migrants – and all migrants use this – are now offering other services. The airtime that these migrants are using, because it’s getting cheaper to call home, is booming. Those same customers go to money transfer operators to send funds to their families. They share that customer. Telcos are therefore trying to figure out how to offer their clients, who use their airtime minutes, remittance services. Some are getting licenses to become money transmitters, and that’s complicated because regulations in each state are complicated. Others are trying to offer financial services with their apps, making the bridge between the two services.

As you are aware, regulatory pressures have caused a number of banks to discontinue their remittances operations. What impact did this have in the remittances industry as a whole?

HC: The situation has really made a large turn in the past year. Regulatory pressure has made a number of banks in the US and the UK drop the remittance operations – like Bank of America, Chase, and TD Bank – and at the same time drop banking money transfer operators.

A number of transmitters in the US and UK are losing their bank accounts – banks don’t want to bank them any longer. That has created a very big program. Many are worried because MSBs are losing their bank accounts. So what do they do with the funds? Some have to close down, while larger players have bought others.

But the ripple effect in this is that money transfer operators and financial services providers in places like Latin America and the Caribbean are losing their US bank accounts, too. Those companies abroad that need US bank accounts to move money around and better provide their services don’t have international bank accounts, and now their domestic bank accounts are closing down because their correspondent bank in the US doesn’t want those money transfer operations to go through their wire transfer. That situation is getting worse by the minute. There is a lot of pressure not only due to the risk that some banks are taking in having these accounts, but also because of the cost of the compliance to keep these accounts open.

The few banks that are still banking the industry are increasing the cost for MSBs to handle those bank accounts because they have to spend more money on compliance, software, people, etc. So even if the price for money transfer has been dropping, that probably won’t continue. That’s why the World Bank is worried – less competition will mean that prices will go up.

It is very hard to address regulation without mentioning virtual currencies, in particular Bitcoin. We have seen situations where consumers would choose Bitcoin over more traditional services such as Western Union or MoneyGram. What are your thoughts on this?

HC: In the next few years, I don’t think we will see much happening. But yes, it’s very important for the future. At IMTC, we’re launching a course on virtual currencies for money transfer professionals. I do think that people in this industry have to see and understand what is happening in the digital currency world, and not just judge it from the outside. Even the technologies and protocols of the currency are changing things. I think that bitcoin really has a future in this industry, but this all will take time, and of course, regulation will play a major role here, all over the world.

It is very hard to address regulation without mentioning virtual currencies, in particular Bitcoin. We have seen situations where consumers would choose Bitcoin over more traditional services such as Western Union or MoneyGram. What are your thoughts on this?

HC: In the next few years, I don’t think we will see much happening. But yes, it’s very important for the future. At IMTC, we’re launching a course on virtual currencies for money transfer professionals. I do think that people in this industry have to see and understand what is happening in the digital currency world, and not just judge it from the outside. Even the technologies and protocols of the currency are changing things. I think that bitcoin really has a future in this industry, but this all will take time, and of course, regulation will play a major role here, all over the world.

You have recently released an infographic illustrates that while the international money transfer market keeps on growing, the total cost of sending remittances has been failing. What impact does this have to all the different players in this ecosystem (telcos, MTOs and banks)?

HC: The infographic has been an exercise, and besides looking at data like the dropping of remittances worldwide, it tries to summarize the friction points of the players in the industry. It touches on the banks’ continuance problem, the fact that banks are moving away from the remittance market, the problem with no one wanting cash and everyone wanting mobile phones, and transaction costs – how telcos are used to lower margins than MTOs or banks. Branding, too, is very important in this. Finally, it summarizes the affect on financial inclusion, especially in places where the lower class is using mobile phones and services.

So the infographic shows where the battlefields are and what’s happening in each country, offering a worldwide perspective. Those who download it can get a general view, hopefully leading them to reach their own conclusions and help their companies decide what move to make next.

For more information on how the money transfer market is growing and impacting countries around the world, download the IMTC infographic here. For a more detailed document on this issue, download it from here.

Category: News & CommentsBy Hugo Cuevas-MohrSeptember 16, 2014
Share this post
Share on FacebookShare on Facebook TweetShare on Twitter

Post navigation

PreviousPrevious post:FINCEN Director’s Remarks 8/12/2014NextNext post:Bank Discontinuance, the G20 and the taxing of remittances

Related Posts

Love & Death: Agents vs. Digital
May 25, 2020
RCTF – The Private Sector Workstream – April 30, 2020 Virtual Roundtable
May 2, 2020
Creativity in Times of Hibernation
April 18, 2020
Remittance Community Task Force: Facing the Challenges of COVID-19
March 31, 2020
A new decade for us
January 30, 2020
laBITconf 2019 in its 7th Edition
December 23, 2019

PNET Logo
The CrossTech Conferences are developed by The Platinum Network, producer of the CrossTech Innovation Awards --formerly the Remtech Awards-- and the CrossTech Compliance Conference. --formerly Regliance--

THE PLATINUM NETWORK
7700 N Kendall Dr Suite 407
Miami, Florida 33156

WhatsApp: +1 (786) 731-5507

Important Links
IMTC in Twitter
IMTC Linkedin Group
IMTC in YouTube
IMTC in Facebook
IMTC in Instagram

Terms & Conditions
Visa Letter Information
Privacy & Cookie Policy
Hotel Reservation Fraud
Latest Tweets
  • #ApplePayLater users will be able to manage, track and repay their loans in their #Apple Wallet, the company said i… twitter.com/i/web/status/16411…

    Ayer a las 9:23 pm

  • The Miami Downtown Development Authority (DDA) is the economic agency for the City of Miami’s urban core. It mainta… twitter.com/i/web/status/16408…

    March 28, 2023 9:58 pm

WhatsApp us