Pular para o conteúdo
CrossTech is part of The Platinum Network. Become a Member!
  • enEnglish
  • esEspañol
  • pt-brPortuguês
Linkedin page opens in new windowYouTube page opens in new windowTwitter page opens in new windowFacebook page opens in new windowInstagram page opens in new window
CrossTech
Cross Border Payments
CrossTechCrossTech
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Board of Directors
    • Who comes to CROSSTECH?
    • Industry Associations
    • WOMEN IN THE MONEY TRANSFER INDUSTRY AWARDS
    • IDFR – International Day of Family Remittances
    • Contact Us
  • Conferences
    • PAYMENTS 2023
    • Past Conferences
      • IMTC WORLD
        • WORLD 2022
        • IMTC WORLD 2021
        • IMTC WORLD 2020
      • IMTC LATAM
        • LATAM 2022
        • IMTC LATAM 2021
        • IMTC LATAM 2019
      • REGLIANCE
        • REGLIANCE 2021
      • IMTC EMEA
        • IMTC EMEA 2021
        • IMTC EMEA 2019
        • IMTC EMEA 2018
      • IMTC ASIA
        • IMTC ASIA 2018
        • IMTC ASIA 2016
      • IMTC AFRICA
        • IMTC AFRICA 2019
        • IMTC AFRICA 2017
      • IMTC BRASIL
        • IMTC BRASIL 2018
        • IMTC BRASIL 2016
      • REMTECH AWARDS
        • CROSSTECH AWARDS 2022
        • REMTECH 2020
        • REMTECH AWARDS 2019
    • Past & Present Sponsors
    • Past Speakers
    • Past Participants
  • Magazine
  • Blog
Search:
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Board of Directors
    • Who comes to CROSSTECH?
    • Industry Associations
    • WOMEN IN THE MONEY TRANSFER INDUSTRY AWARDS
    • IDFR – International Day of Family Remittances
    • Contact Us
  • Conferences
    • PAYMENTS 2023
    • Past Conferences
      • IMTC WORLD
        • WORLD 2022
        • IMTC WORLD 2021
        • IMTC WORLD 2020
      • IMTC LATAM
        • LATAM 2022
        • IMTC LATAM 2021
        • IMTC LATAM 2019
      • REGLIANCE
        • REGLIANCE 2021
      • IMTC EMEA
        • IMTC EMEA 2021
        • IMTC EMEA 2019
        • IMTC EMEA 2018
      • IMTC ASIA
        • IMTC ASIA 2018
        • IMTC ASIA 2016
      • IMTC AFRICA
        • IMTC AFRICA 2019
        • IMTC AFRICA 2017
      • IMTC BRASIL
        • IMTC BRASIL 2018
        • IMTC BRASIL 2016
      • REMTECH AWARDS
        • CROSSTECH AWARDS 2022
        • REMTECH 2020
        • REMTECH AWARDS 2019
    • Past & Present Sponsors
    • Past Speakers
    • Past Participants
  • Magazine
  • Blog

The Money Services Banking Crisis

Você está aqui:
  1. Início
  2. De-Risking
  3. The Money Services Banking Crisis
Jun222016
De-Risking

The Money Services Banking Crisis: A Complex Solution for a Simple Problem

Commentary by Andrew S. Ittleman, Daily Business Review
June 20, 2016 | Published in the Daily Business Review

Money services businesses, a broad category of nonbank financial institutions running the gamut from brick-and-mortar money transmitters, check cashers and currency exchangers to more modern e-wallet and prepaid access providers and bitcoin exchangers, provide millions of Americans with financial services they cannot receive from banks.

To show how critical MSBs are to the functioning of the U.S. financial system, a 2013 Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. survey found 9.6 million U.S. households did not have bank accounts and 24.8 million households — 20 percent of the U.S. population — were underbanked, meaning they had bank accounts but also used alternative financial services outside of the banking system

Today, MSBs worldwide are caught in a banking crisis showing no signs of relenting. Based on real and imagined enforcement risks, most banks have categorically decided against providing accounts to MSBs, while others have been ordered by regulators to stop serving MSBs. This process of “de-risking,” by which banks terminate relationships with “high-risk” customers, has been brutal for the MSB industry and resulted in unforeseen consequences, including:

• Banks as de facto regulators

Banks have become the primary MSB industry regulators, a role they neither desire nor can fulfill. Even for MSBs with the required state licenses and Financial Crimes Enforcement Network registration, banks hold the exclusive authority to decide which MSBs live or die, and exercise this authority without due process or standards comporting with the rulemaking requirements of any first-world jurisdiction.

• Elimination of MSBs

Many longstanding MSBs have ceased operations because of a lack of access to banks. Startups offering digital and virtual solutions for their customers have failed for the same reason. All of this leads to fewer choices, poorer service and higher prices for MSB customers.

• Unsafe and unsound financial activities

Some MSBs have clouded the nature of their businesses to open bank accounts, defeating the banks’ anti-money laundering programs. By deceiving banks, numerous MSBs have committed federal felony offenses and been criminally prosecuted. In other cases, as recently reported by the Wall Street Journal, money transmitters have been forced to fly cash-filled duffel bags to Dubai for distribution throughout the Middle East and Africa because banks in the U.S. have ceased providing accounts to MSBs serving the African diaspora. Rather than allowing these transfers to occur bank-to-bank and under the U.S. government’s watchful eye, the banking crisis has driven huge volumes of money underground, benefiting none more than the international black-market financial system.

Buy-in Needed

As simple as the problem may be, the solution requires the full buy-in and cooperation of regulators, banks and the MSB industry.

While various domestic and international governmental bodies — including Financial Action Task Force, Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council and FinCEN — have made clear that banks can and should service the MSB industry commensurate with their anti-money laundering responsibilities, these announcements are not binding on the agencies regulating banks or the agencies’ employees and examiners. Without consistency in these announcements, banks will remain concerned about inconsistent enforcement, and continue making financially motivated business decisions to stay away from MSBs.

But blaming banks for the banking crisis accomplishes nothing. They have only recently emerged from a historical era of government enforcement with billion-dollar fines stemming from unsafe, unsound and/or fraudulent business activities. No wonder they want to avoid high-risk accounts. If banks should be criticized for anything it is lack of vision or a failure to recognize the benefits MSB clients bring. In addition to dealing in money as their inventory and often being required to maintain sizable cash deposits to remain compliant with state licensing laws, MSBs have access to advanced financial technology, customer bases, and international partners that could benefit US banks suffering from a generational shift in trust and goodwill.

So, who should take the lead in this issue? Without a doubt, the MSB industry — and with a single voice. Among other critical issues that the industry must continue to champion is how MSBs can support law enforcement and anti-money laundering initiatives, encourage financial inclusion and accelerate international commerce.

IMTC & MSBA

The International Money Transfer Conferences (IMTC) are an excellent platform for this discussion, and hopefully the conferences continue to expand. The Money Services Businesses Association (MSBA), which I helped create with key members of the industry and other MSB attorneys and consultants, also provides a valuable resource and platform. Through these combined efforts and ideally with the with the help of the international banking community and its regulators, MSBs will soon find banks that wish to have them as customers.

Categoria: De-RiskingPor Hugo Cuevas-MohrJune 22, 2016
Share this post
Share on FacebookShare on Facebook TweetShare on Twitter

Navegação de post:

AnteriorPost anterior:Migration & Remittances: Global TrendsPróximoPróximo post:IMTC CUBA 2016: a breakthrough

Related Posts

RCTF – The Private Sector Workstream – April 30, 2020 Virtual Roundtable
May 2, 2020
Customer Expectations In The Payments Industry
March 5, 2020
Digital vs. Cash, are we getting it all wrong?
June 10, 2018
THE FUTURE OF PAYMENTS: MTOs, PIs, REMTECH & THE BLOCKCHAIN
March 3, 2018
CHILE: WHERE MIGRANTS BECOME AN EVERYDAY SURPRISE
February 13, 2018
QUÉ NOS DEJÓ EL 2017
December 19, 2017
Are you a PNET Member?

If you have not joined our industry community yet, go to PNET and sign up. You can get membership perks and discounts for IMTC conferences!

Keep on Learning!
Check our online courses:

MTTC Money Transfer Compliance Certication Course. Check the version in English &  la versión en Español.
Watch video presentation of our courses here.

PNET Logo
The CrossTech Conferences are developed by The Platinum Network, producer of the CrossTech Innovation Awards --formerly the Remtech Awards-- and the CrossTech Compliance Conference. --formerly Regliance--

THE PLATINUM NETWORK
7700 N Kendall Dr Suite 407
Miami, Florida 33156

WhatsApp: +1 (786) 731-5507

Important Links
IMTC in Twitter
IMTC Linkedin Group
IMTC in YouTube
IMTC in Facebook
IMTC in Instagram

Terms & Conditions
Visa Letter Information
Privacy & Cookie Policy
Hotel Reservation Fraud
Latest Tweets
  • We are proud to announce one more speaker coming to CrossTech Payments 2023. Let's welcome Ashley Mallett! Ashley… twitter.com/i/web/status/16393…

    March 24, 2023 7:32 pm

  • Today, during the VRT in partnership with TRIBE, our COO, Priscilla D'Oliveira Friedman, talked a little bit about… twitter.com/i/web/status/16390…

    March 24, 2023 12:03 am

WhatsApp us